Transgender,genderless in distress

Talk about anything you want here. From current events to nerd news to pointless ranting. All's fair here.

Moderator: Suicide

Post Reply
User avatar
yetie
Posts: 2103
Joined: November 26th, 2011, 8:53 pm

Transgender,genderless in distress

Post by yetie »

First i like to say this is not something posted to lure respons or native reactien this is a real question i got, i realy want to know a anser or a guide line, so i ask.

A few days ago i checkt a cartoon, in that serie a woman gets tied up and gagged.
That woman looks like a woman and her voice is like a woman, but some were at the end of the episode during a flashback it is reveled that when she was 8 she was a he(dont know if it is crossdress of transgender).
This got me thinking: hey i want to make a post, but were should i post it, what are the ''rules'' for this?
Should i go by : she was born a boy so a GID or by: she looks like a woman so DID or she plays a woman so DID.
If it goes by looks were is the line, i have seen animes were boys are tied up but when you dont see the anime only the picture of the tied up you think :female.
A another example : in American dad the alien got no gender(i searched it online and in the show it has been said)
But in 1 episode Roger dressed as a woman.
So once again were should these be posted on.
sawxd
Posts: 327
Joined: July 15th, 2012, 9:28 pm

Re: Transgender,genderless in distress

Post by sawxd »

i have by far the same question , i personal dislike GID but i like some "guys" who looks like girls i wanna see in distress like Hideri of Blend S or Haku or woman who looks like boy example Seishiro Tsugumi of Nisekoi or Naoto of persona 4 , i have a folder in devianart called TIP (Trap in distress) i think we should put where the person posting feels more comfortable but clear out the gender of the "damsel" ... i dunno is a really hard question :v
I put my screenpics way before in my DA Account : https://www.deviantart.com/sawxd
User avatar
Suicide
Posts: 3536
Joined: May 24th, 2011, 1:26 pm
Contact:

Re: Transgender,genderless in distress

Post by Suicide »

I'm not going to set a definitive rule for this really. I'll leave it up to the person posting where they would like to place a particular transgender/genderless character. It's hardly frequent enough to post up a rule about so just use your own discretion. :) Good question though!
Image
MakeupAndTieup

Re: Transgender,genderless in distress

Post by MakeupAndTieup »

Well I don't like transgenders in distress. I'm picky enough when the damsel is cis female.

As for genderless? It's hard to say. I see the crystal gems as genderless and I'm not sure what to think of them..
Post Reply